My last post on Lee Kaplan mentioned "a recent action of his that is too horrible to share." But given the latest developments, it can now be discussed.
Last month, in his hysterical campaign against the International Solidarity Movement, Kaplan hit a new low (even for himself, and that's saying a lot), and published a confidential plea from a misguided but loving father who was concerned about his son's involvement with the ISM. Going directly against the wishes of the father and wreaking havoc on a family, by publishing his emails, Kaplan shows that there are no bounds to his visceral and illogical hatred of the ISM and the lengths he will go to in order to attack it.
But those used and abused by Kaplan are now speaking up. Brian Malovany and his father, Robert Malovany, have responded to Kaplan's ruthless attack, and I publish their words here, with their permission. Lee Kaplan Watch has also posted this, and others should spread the word about it, too.
---------------------
Hello,
My name is Brian Malovany, and I am a volunteer with the
International Solidarity Movement. Until the murder of Rachel Corrie, I had not
heard of the ISM, but since then I have done everything I could to support the
non-violent resistance of the Palestinian people against the Israeli occupation
and ethnic cleansing, and I am proud to do so. I have been lucky to visit
Palestine twice in the past 2 years, and I have made many friends as a result,
Palestinians, Israelis and Internationals. The work of ISM and countless other
groups in Palestine/Israel is not easy or without risk, but it is incredibly
important; such as demonstrating against the theft of land in Bil'in, working
with medical teams in Balata refugee camp retrieving murdered Palestinians from
their homes, or walking children to school in the Tel Rumeida neighborhood of
Hebron, where they are harassed by racist and violent Israeli settlers.
That said, working with ISM has not come without a price. As in many
other Jewish-American families, the issue of Palestine/Israel is a very divisive
and painful one, an issue which is surrounded by a web of fear, hysteria and
ignorance. Despite being the only member of my immediate family to have ever
visited there, it is still very difficult to get across to them just how
incredible my experiences there have been. Along with such issues of politics
and Jewish identity, my family has had its share of difficulties and clashes,
like many other families. It is obvious that we all need to learn to listen to
each other, accept each other's differences, and to never lose hold of the love
that we all share.
Although Lee Kaplan and his ilk take great pride in
smearing us and writing their lies on the internet, it is of no real
consequence; he is a truly pitiful man that almost no one takes seriously,
including me. I had always thought that, no matter how blinded by his support
for Israel my father becomes, he would be able to see clearly the racism and
stupidity in Lee Kaplan's "investigative journalism." Unfortunately, that was
not the case, but he now knows just what a dishonorable and untrustworthy man
that he is.
Since nothing can be retracted from the internet, I offer my
father's apology for the record, for what it is worth. To all who have supported
me in this debacle, I thank you from the bottom of my heart.
in
solidarity,
Brian Malovany
-------------------------------------
Dear Brian,
What can
I say?
The Kaplan letter was a mistake to put it mildly. I had every
reason to believe that my communication was going to be private and
confidential. I was betrayed. I was used.
Yet, I bear total
responsibility for what happened. I should have known better. I exercised
faulty judgement and I regret this. It was never my intent to hurt you or to be
cruel to you. You do not deserve this.
But at lest it gives me the
opportunity to say things to you that I should have been saying regularly for a
long time. Brian, I love you. I love you more than I love my life. A day
does not go by that I don't think about you and worry about you. Of course that
I worry about you is not your responsibilty. Parents worry about their
children, it goes with the territory. But I think I have carried this worrying
to an irrational and unhealthy extent. Since the Kaplan stuff came out, I have
not slept and have been deeply upset at my helplessness to make everything
right. I guess this will take some time. I don't know what else to do. But
remember again, that your mother and I have not ever rejected you, we love you
dearly. You always have a home here with us if you should ever need it. We are
there for you.
I love you Brian. I may not have shown this as well as I
should have, but please know that it is true and it will always be
true.
Love,
Dad
Recent Comments